It’s not often that I read an opinion piece that totally makes sense. This finally explains in a logical way why the Republicans have made illegal immigration such a big deal. This was written by Robert Kistner and was published in the Mesa Tribune on Wednesday, December 26th, 2007. Mr. Kistner states that he “is involved in education and business.”
GOP needs villain, found one in “illegals’
Creating monsters comes easier than solutions.
Son, here’s tonight’s Republican bedtime story.
Once upon a time, there was a national political party that had been in power for 14 years, but was in a panic because its policies had failed. There was a trillion dollar deficit, a health care crisis, the country’s infrastructure was decaying, the war was a disaster, and the party’s leader, the president, was widely disliked.
So one day the leaders of this party called in people who worked for them in their think tanks and said, “Well, what the heck do we do now? It seems like we’re cooked.”
“Oh no, no, no, no!” responded the men in the black-and-tweed suits, whose eyes seemed to roll around in their sockets, as if they had been doing a lot of thinking. “We have another plan, you know, another Strategic Initiative that will distract the people from those other unfortunate issues. This may be the best red herring we’ve come up with yet. We’re going to call it the ‘Immigrant as Monsters’ Strategic Initiative. Remember, it’s all about framing, framing, framing the debate.
“But” responded one of the younger, more inexperienced members of the party, “that won’t work, because most of the immigrants aren’t monsters. They’re mostly just hard-working people who work hard to support their families. And most people know that.”
There was a silence in the room, then thunderous laughter. “He’s new,” one of the senior senators responded. “Son, reality doesn’t have all that much to do with it. We’ve got to motivate our base, and the best way to do it is to create a monster to destroy. There’s got to be fear, so we can protect the people from danger.”
“Heck, the monster can be a person like Saddam Hussein or an idea like unfair taxes. This time it’ll be immigrants. It’s beautiful. Some of the immigrants are illegally here and therefore they are criminals, monsters. Our party will be the hero that rides in to save America from the beasts. This stuff works every time.”
The Think Tankers looked pleased. “We have already planned out some of the details of the Initiative. We’ve got the position papers, the press releases, the preliminary TV ads and the talking points ready, and we have gotten buy-in from the Noise Machine. Corporate media has totally bought in. Rush and Sean are salivating with expectation. Ailes with FOX is apoplectic with joy. Dobbs is set to demagogue this issue from every imaginable angle. And to think everyone thought we were cooked this year on the issues.”
“It seems wrong to me.” The freshman senator had spoken again. “It seems unethical to just go on a blanket campaign to demonize all those workers. Hey, two of them work for me, landscaping. They’re the hardest workers you can imagine, and polite, and good Catholics. Besides, there are 12 million already in the U.S. You mean we’re going to deport them all or put them in jail? That’s crazy.”
“Besides,” he went on, “it’s not American. It’s not principled. And at least the local media are too smart to buy into this.”
“What are you talking about? Hey, there’s a columnist in Phoenix who is ready with a column called: ‘If Arizona is lagging, immigration is the reason.’ He actually blames all Arizona’s social problems on the immigrants.”
One of the senior senators grabbed the freshman around the shoulders and said, “Come with me son, I’ll explain to you how this all works.” “Winning politics is based on fear, not fairness or human dignity or rights or all that liberal nonsense. It’s about motivating your base. I’ll buy you some lunch and fill you in on how this all really works. I’ll start by explaining the idea of a Strategic Initiative.”
Well, that’s tonight’s Republican bedtime story, son. And sleep well. Remember, monsters don’t exist unless you think they do.”